Wren

Can a crisis plan reduce the chance of hospital care against my wishes?

There is some evidence that making a crisis plan with support reduces hospital admission against a person's wishes.

The studies included bipolar and illnesses involving psychosis, meaning losing touch with reality, so the benefit specifically for bipolar remains uncertain. A crisis plan records care wishes and agrees how help will be offered if someone becomes very unwell. Making it takes discussion, and the people responding need to be able to find and use it. The plan can include requests for help as well as treatments the person wants to avoid.⁠

How much difference planning made

A review of five controlled trials found about a quarter lower chance of being admitted against a person’s wishes with crisis planning than with ordinary care. The number of people who avoid such an admission depends on how common it is in each setting. Voluntary admissions and the total number of admissions were similar overall. A plan may therefore help care happen by agreement while hospital care is still sometimes needed.⁠

The studies had mixed results. One of those trials in England involved 160 people making a plan with a psychiatrist, a doctor specialising in mental health. A care coordinator helped organise care, and a facilitator helped the discussion reach agreement. Over fifteen months, compulsory admission or treatment occurred in about 13 in 100 making the joint plan and 27 in 100 receiving ordinary care. A later, larger trial found similar compulsory-admission outcomes across groups. These trials contributed to the review's combined result.⁠

Another trial in the review, conducted in the Netherlands, found fewer admissions ordered by a court with planning. Emergency admission against someone's wishes and admission by agreement were similar across groups. Which part of care improves can depend on the service and legal setting as well as the plan.⁠

Why agreeing and using the plan matter

Making a plan is only the first part of getting wishes heard. The review found problems with incomplete plans, meetings that gave little room for joint discussion and preferences that were later overlooked. A plan needs to be available to the people responding, with agreement about what can happen and how it will be used. Those practical steps help make the effort of planning worthwhile, although the amount of extra benefit remains uncertain.⁠

Fewer admissions are also only one possible aim. Some people with bipolar want earlier voluntary admission to prevent spending, relationship damage or other harm during a high. Others most want a particular treatment, a calmer setting or contact with someone they trust. A review of advance planning in bipolar found that requests as well as refusals matter.⁠

Preparing for the care the person wants

A plan recording care wishes before decisions become difficult is worth considering when previous crises have involved care that felt frightening or out of the person's control. Making a crisis plan and Making an Advance Choice Document explain how to prepare one. It can state what has helped, what made matters worse, who should be contacted and when the person would want hospital help. The person can discuss it in advance with those likely to respond, agree who keeps copies and check how it will be found in a crisis. Reviewing it after use gives a way to see whether care followed the person's wishes and what needs changing.⁠

Sources

  1. 1Crisis-planning interventions for people with psychotic illness or bipolar disorder: systematic review and meta-analyses Review
  2. 2Advance Decision Making in Bipolar: A Systematic Review Bipolar planning review
  3. 3Effect of joint crisis plans on use of compulsory treatment in psychiatry: single blind randomised controlled trial English trial
  4. 4Effect of Crisis Plans on Admissions and Emergency Visits: A Randomized Controlled Trial Trial

Last updated 12 October 2026